strafsachen.at
Property crimes

An absolutely impossible fraud attempt: When an attempt is not punishable

Section 15(3) StGB: Why failed fraud may remain punishable and how the defence distinguishes absolute from relative impossibility in Austria.

Your personal attorney

Mag. Christopher Angerer, Rechtsanwalt

Your lawyer for criminal defence

Criminal proceedings are a matter of trust. One lawyer who walks with you from the first consultation through to the trial, everything from one hand.

8 November 2026, Mag. Christopher Angerer, Rechtsanwalt

§ 15 Abs 3 StGB exempts attempted fraud from punishment if completion was impossible under any circumstances, yet this exception remains narrow. Neither the absence of financial loss, a successful check, nor a court refusing an application suffices on its own. For business owners and other accused persons, the key questions are why the alleged plan failed and whether the type of conduct could ever have produced the intended loss.

Why could the alleged fraud not succeed?

Would you like to discuss the case?

01 Question 1

Which situation concerns your allegation?

Overview

Why could the alleged fraud not succeed?

01

Examine safeguards and relative impossibility

Keep the contract, release conditions and correspondence. An effective check alone does not make an attempt unpunishable. Ask the defence to assess whether this was only an obstacle in the particular case.

02

Test fundamental impossibility against the alleged plan

Bring together the alleged deception, the intended disposition and the obstacle. The defence needs to assess impossibility under the statutory test before relying on § 15 Abs 3 StGB.

03

Examine the entire transaction and the judgment’s findings

Have the application, exhibits and decisions ready. A refused application does not establish absolute impossibility. Obtain an assessment of the full factual basis and the appropriate procedural step.

What test does § 15 Abs 3 StGB set?

Section 15 StGB generally extends penalties for intentional offences to attempts. Under Abs 2, conduct immediately preceding execution must manifest the decision to commit the offence. In fraud cases, the defence must also examine whether intent covered deception about facts, a harmful disposition of assets, and unlawful enrichment through the deceived person's conduct. A mere plan and the absence of intent are separate issues to resolve before considering impossibility.

Under § 15 Abs 3 StGB, an attempt and participation in it are not punishable if the personal characteristics or circumstances specified there, or the nature of the conduct or its object, made completion impossible under any circumstances. For the conduct, the Austrian Supreme Court (OGH) requires a generalised assessment from the perspective before the act: a reasonable observer who knows the plan considers whether the intended result, by the proposed method, appears entirely excluded. The eventual outcome alone does not answer that question.

Why detection and particular caution usually do not suffice

Relative impossibility arises when conduct could in principle produce the result, yet specific circumstances block its completion. In 11 Os 106/07h of 23 October 2007, the OGH expressly highlighted the victim's particular caution. If a person recognises an alleged deception and therefore refuses payment, that action does not render the attempt absolutely impossible.

The defence needs to identify why the attempt failed. A check, a follow-up question, or a contradiction detected in time may have stopped a course of events that was possible in principle. That decision holds that even a low prospect of success does not establish an exemption from punishment. The argument must explain why completion was excluded under the statutory test; merely describing a particularly effective check is insufficient.

Property purchase escrow: A safeguard is no exemption

In 13 Os 124/20i of 16 March 2021, the allegation concerned deceiving a property seller about ability and willingness to pay. The original contract was to remain with its drafter until the purchase price had been paid in full, and the accused argued that this meant land register implementation could not have been initiated. The OGH held that neither the established contract wording nor the other facts found in the judgment supported this far-reaching assumption.

The OGH also classified the situation as a merely relatively impossible fraud attempt, noting that arranging for registration only after payment did not make completion absolutely impossible. In 11 Os 106/07h, it had already pointed to the possibility of registration obstacles being overlooked. Accused persons therefore need a close examination of the escrow agreement and transaction rules. Saying that an escrow holder should have prevented the loss does not, on its own, support the exemption argument.

A refused application: What the OGH examines in litigation fraud

An unsuccessful civil case does not establish absolute impossibility either. In the 27 July 2022 decision 15 Os 10/22t, one allegation concerned a possession disturbance claim, false assertions, and backdated tenancy agreements. The applicant sought a court order to transfer possession, yet the court refused the application. The OGH rejected the impossibility argument because the appeal ignored the full set of established acts and relied instead on a later judgment and an isolated item of evidence.

The decision also reveals the limits of arguing that no loss was established, as findings on another count supported at least a punishable attempted fraud. The defence therefore needs to distinguish a failure to prove completed financial harm from an alleged impossibility of any completion. Where deception in court is alleged, one must consider the entire application, the facts asserted, and the intended harmful effect on assets together.

Which facts and documents the defence needs

The assessment begins by identifying who was supposed to be mistaken about what, which disposition of assets was supposed to follow, and which loss the alleged intent covered. The next question asks what prevented the plan from succeeding. These questions help distinguish an actual obstacle from conduct that is fundamentally incapable of producing the result, and they do not replace separate scrutiny of whether deception and the commencement of a punishable attempt can be proved at all.

The full contract, escrow instructions, release conditions, and messages from the time of contracting matter for a contractual transaction, while the application, exhibits, and decisions belong together for court proceedings. Keep original documents and complete correspondence so the defence can use them to assess whether the asserted impossibility is grounded in the facts and what further evidence is needed. A later short account of the safeguards may leave out important steps.

How a sound argument is used in proceedings

The defence should clarify the factual basis early during proceedings and apply the statutory test to the specific allegation. A legal challenge must start from the findings once a judgment exists. The argument in 13 Os 124/20i failed precisely because it relied on a premise outside those findings, and Decision 15 Os 10/22t likewise requires all relevant findings to be considered together. An alternative account of events does not replace the appropriate form of challenge.

When § 15 Abs 3 StGB applies, the attempt and participation in it are not punishable, yet this does not grant a blanket exemption for the entire course of events. Separate allegations, such as those concerning false evidence used, require their own legal assessment. Have the indictment or judgment examined together with the relevant business records so the defence can determine whether absolute impossibility, another missing element of the offence, or an evidential issue supports the case.

Frequently asked questions

Impossible attempts and fraud allegations

Is attempted fraud unpunishable if no money was lost? +

The absence of financial loss may indicate that the offence remained an attempt, and Section 15 StGB generally covers such attempts as well. The exemption under Abs 3 requires that completion was impossible under any circumstances on the grounds specified there. Intent, commencement of the attempt, and the other elements of the allegation still need examination.

Is a particularly secure escrow arrangement enough? +

For property purchases, the OGH has treated an arrangement requiring payment before registration as merely relative impossibility. Therefore, a safeguard alone does not establish an exemption from punishment. The decisive factors are the established plan, the entire transaction, and the statutory test for possible completion.

Do I have to prove absolute impossibility myself? +

Accused persons are not required to prove their innocence, yet a specific defence argument still demands careful examination of the facts and evidence. Any legal challenge to a judgment must begin with its findings, and the appropriate steps depend on both the stage of proceedings and the contents of the case file.

Interview, house search, indictment?

In criminal matters every hour counts. Call us directly or send an email, callback within one business day, earlier in urgent cases.

Contact

A direct line to the firm.

Address

BRANDAUER Rechtsanwälte GmbH Giselakai 51 5020 Salzburg