Confiscation under § 26 StGB: protecting affected objects
Facing confiscation under § 26 StGB in Austria? Assess the special characteristics, removal of the danger and protection for uninvolved owners before the decision becomes final.
Mag. Christopher Angerer, Rechtsanwalt
Your lawyer for criminal defence
Criminal proceedings are a matter of trust. One lawyer who walks with you from the first consultation through to the trial, everything from one hand.
§ 26 StGB provides for confiscation of objects only when their special characteristics necessitate removal to prevent further punishable acts. The mere use of a machine, vehicle, or tool in an offence does not suffice on its own. Consequently, affected businesses and owners need to examine the specific characteristics and the statutory options for preserving the object.
Before the decision becomes final, give particular attention to whether the special characteristics can be removed or an uninvolved rights holder can provide assurance of safe use. Reliable evidence must support these options. The high value of business equipment and a mere promise about future conduct do not replace the statutory requirements. Seek prompt legal assessment of the documents if a hearing is approaching or a decision has already been pronounced.
What remains unresolved about the proposed confiscation?
Would you like to discuss the case?
Which issue concerns your object?
Your answers so far
Coordinate lawful removal and evidence of the result.
Document entitlement and assurance of safe use.
The connection to the offence required by § 26 StGB
The connection to the offence required by § 26 StGB
§ 26 Abs. 1 StGB encompasses objects that the offender used to commit the punishable act or intended for that purpose, as well as objects produced by that act. One must establish the connection for the particular object, and a general description as business equipment fails to answer either the question of its connection to the offence or that of its special characteristics.
Confiscation serves a preventive purpose. Under § 26 Abs. 3 StGB, the court may order it where the requirements are met even if no particular person can be prosecuted or convicted for the act. Consequently, the prospect of discontinued proceedings or an acquittal does not automatically resolve the issue concerning the object. The findings regarding the act and each individual object require separate assessment.
Why use in an offence is insufficient on its own
Why use in an offence is insufficient on its own
The decisive issue is whether the object’s special characteristics make it suitable for criminal use. The Austrian Supreme Court (OGH) emphasises this standard in its established case law under RS0121298. A finding that an object was used in the offence does not suffice to assess the requirements for confiscation, and the accused person’s agreement does not replace the statutory requirements either.
Therefore, the assessment must identify the special characteristic that renders preventive confiscation necessary for ordinary tools or other business equipment. No blanket exemption exists for everything a business needs. An accurate description, documented condition, and, where appropriate, expert assessment matter for the defence. Any assertion of danger must be measured against verifiable characteristics.
Removing the special characteristics to preserve the object
Removing the special characteristics to preserve the object
When the rights holder removes the special characteristics, § 26 Abs. 2 Satz 1 StGB obliges the court to refrain from confiscation. The statute explicitly lists the removal or disabling of devices or markings that facilitate acts punishable by law. The decisive factor is the effective removal of the relevant characteristic; a mere offer to make a change later does not yet equate to having done so.
A legal assessment should first identify the disputed characteristic, determine whether it can be removed lawfully and in a technically appropriate manner, and establish how to prove the result. If the authorities hold the object, you must not arrange unauthorised alterations. You must coordinate expert assessment and any permissible work within the proceedings. Refraining from confiscation does not automatically mean immediate return if another legal ground for retaining the object exists.
The assurance required from an uninvolved rights holder
The assurance required from an uninvolved rights holder
§ 26 Abs. 2 Satz 2 StGB applies where a person uninvolved in the offence holds legal claims to the object. In such cases, confiscation remains permissible only if that person fails to provide assurance that the object will not be used to commit offences. Consequently, third-party ownership does not by itself exclude confiscation. Authorities must assess non-involvement and the assurance regarding future use separately.
For an affected business, the relevant questions may include who would have access after return and how lawful use would be reliably organised. That assessment may depend on clear responsibilities and effective access restrictions. Whether these measures suffice in the individual case depends on the object and the circumstances. A mere declaration of ownership or transfer to another person does not in itself provide reliable safeguards.
Evidence supporting objections to confiscation
Evidence supporting objections to confiscation
Preparation should clearly identify the individual object, and contracts, invoices, payment and delivery records, along with any serial or identification numbers, can help. Where a company is involved, the documents must show whether it or another person holds the right. An entry in the fixed asset register may support that attribution but does not resolve every civil-law ownership question. The confiscation application and existing descriptions of the object should also be preserved.
Evidence of special characteristics and their removal differs from evidence of acquisition. Existing photographs, findings, and expert assessments may document the condition. To establish the assurance offered by an uninvolved rights holder, you must explain the intended use and identify who will be responsible for it. These documents should support specific objections and applications for evidence that address the requirements of § 26 StGB directly.
Exercising procedural rights before the decision becomes final
Exercising procedural rights before the decision becomes final
A person facing confiscation of an object without a personal charge holds the status of a Haftungsbeteiligter, an affected third party to the proceedings, under § 64 StPO. Where the decision concerns that property measure, the person enjoys the rights of the accused at the main hearing and in appeal proceedings, and representation is permitted. However, defending an accused person does not automatically include protecting the separate rights of the owner or company.
§ 444 Abs. 1 StPO permits the main hearing and pronouncement of judgment to proceed in the affected third party’s absence following a proper summons. You must promptly provide the summons, service records, application, and any existing decision. The particular form of proceedings and decision determines the available remedy and deadline. Assess temporary retention, final confiscation, and any application for return separately.
Questions about confiscation under § 26 StGB
Does a machine’s high value prevent confiscation? +
Is a promise of safe future use sufficient? +
Should I arrange removal of the disputed characteristic myself? +
Property measures and procedural rights
Interview, house search, indictment?
In criminal matters every hour counts. Call us directly or send an email, callback within one business day, earlier in urgent cases.
A direct line to the firm.
Address
BRANDAUER Rechtsanwälte GmbH Giselakai 51 5020 Salzburg
Phone
+43 660 2407152