strafsachen.at
Appeals

Extended renewal application: Convention complaint without an ECtHR judgment

Renewal under § 363a StPO before an ECtHR judgment: Convention violation, exhaustion of remedies, four-month time limit and defence counsel signature.

Your personal attorney

Mag. Christopher Angerer, Rechtsanwalt

Your lawyer for criminal defence

Criminal proceedings are a matter of trust. One lawyer who walks with you from the first consultation through to the trial, everything from one hand.

1 November 2026, Mag. Christopher Angerer, Rechtsanwalt

Even before the European Court of Human Rights delivers a judgment, an extended application for renewal of proceedings before the Austrian Supreme Court may be available. A specific violation of the European Convention on Human Rights or one of its protocols by a lower criminal court must be identified by you. Effective remedies must have been exhausted, and the substance of the complaint must already have been raised in the domestic proceedings. Generally, the application is subject to a four-month time limit after the final domestic decision. Defence counsel’s signature is mandatory. Before submitting a fully argued application yourself, have the decision, service records and previous appeals assessed together.

Initial guidance

Which step fits your procedural position?

Select your current situation. This guidance does not replace examination of the case file or a running time limit.

Would you like to describe your procedural position? Open the enquiry form.

01 Question 1

What has already happened in your case?

Overview of all paths

Which procedural situation applies to you?

01

Check the available remedy and its deadline first.

Extended renewal is generally subsidiary while an effective remedy remains available against the challenged decision. Advice should be obtained on how to raise the specific Convention complaint in time and in the correct form through the prescribed procedure. The decision and records of service should be preserved.

What does exhaustion of domestic remedies mean? →
02

Assess admissibility together with the four-month time limit.

Important requirements include exhausted remedies and a complaint already raised in substance. Also to be checked are personal victim status, the specific Convention violation, the final decision, and the four-month time limit. A fully argued application requires defence counsel's signature and is submitted to the Supreme Court.

What time limit applies to an extended renewal application? →
03

Have the complete earlier appeal submissions examined.

The requirement of horizontal exhaustion may not be met by a complaint raised for the first time in the renewal application. Another examination is generally not opened by the application if the Supreme Court has already examined the same complaint. Which restriction applies is determined by the full appeal submissions and decisions.

What Convention violation must the application establish? →
04

Arrange defence assistance before submitting your own application.

A fully argued renewal application lacking defence counsel's signature may fail conclusively. A timely request for the appointment of legal aid defence counsel to prepare this remedy constitutes a different procedural step. Before submitting your own arguments, clarify the form, time limit, and purpose of that request.

Why do counsel’s signature and legal aid matter? →

When is renewal available without a Strasbourg judgment?

The wording of § 363a StPO addresses renewal following an ECtHR judgment. Since decision 13 Os 135/06m of 1 August 2007, applications in which the Austrian Supreme Court assesses the alleged Convention violation itself have also been allowed. Decisions or orders of a criminal court subordinate to the Supreme Court fall within this extended scope. The applicant must personally be affected by the alleged violation. An absolute requirement is not the final conclusion of the entire criminal case; another relevant question is whether effective remedies remain available against the particular decision challenged. If they do, a renewal application may be premature. Therefore, recognition of this remedy in principle does not establish admissibility in an individual case.

What Convention violation must the application establish?

The Convention right concerned and the decision challenged must be clearly identified by the application. By reference to the relevant reasons for that decision, the application must then explain how the particular right was violated and how the violation could have adversely influenced the substance of a criminal court decision. A concrete connection to the case file is needed for an allegation of an unfair trial under Art 6 ECHR. In 12 Os 37/26x of 28 April 2026, the Supreme Court required applicants to address all relevant aspects of the challenged decision. Giving a different personal account of the facts is insufficient. Unless adequately reasoned defects or substantial doubts concerning the findings are demonstrated, the legal argument must proceed from the factual findings in the challenged decision. The application does not create an additional general level of appeal.

What does exhaustion of domestic remedies mean?

Prior use of all effective remedies against the challenged measure is mandatory. Furthermore, the substance of the alleged Convention violation must have been raised during domestic proceedings in compliance with procedural rules. Vertical and horizontal exhaustion of remedies are the names given to these requirements. Consequently, filing an appeal alone is insufficient where that appeal omitted the complaint now relied upon. In 12 Os 37/26x, an argument first raised in the renewal application failed this requirement. Generally, exhaustion is not satisfied by a procedurally defective or late appeal. Conversely, a renewal application cannot secure a repeat examination of the same complaint by the Supreme Court. Without a prior ECtHR judgment, decisions of the Supreme Court itself cannot be challenged through this remedy. Examination of the full reasoning of previous appeals is therefore required.

What time limit applies to an extended renewal application?

By analogy, the four-month time limit under Art 35 Abs 1 ECHR now generally applies. In 15 Os 78/23v of 4 October 2023, the Supreme Court expressly confirmed that the former six-month period was reduced to four months. Following the final domestic decision, the application must be made within that period after domestic remedies have been exhausted. Examination of the relevant decision and its notification or service is required to identify the precise starting point. Service records must be retained even where the date of the decision is already known. Historical references to a six-month time limit are not a reliable basis for an application today. In light of the effective domestic remedies, the deadline for any application to the ECtHR must be assessed separately. An inadmissible renewal application must not be treated as a reliable extension of that deadline.

Why do counsel’s signature and legal aid matter?

Defence counsel must sign a fully argued application by the affected person, which must then be submitted to the Supreme Court. It is particularly risky to submit your own application without that signature. In 13 Os 92/24i of 13 November 2024, the Supreme Court held that this defect cannot be remedied and that the remedy is available only once in the same matter. A subsequent legal aid request did not repair the already defective application in that case. A timely request for appointment of legal aid defence counsel specifically to prepare the renewal application constitutes a different procedural step. According to the same decision, that request can be made within the four-month period, and § 63 Abs 1 StPO governs the subsequent running of time. Individual assessment is required for eligibility for legal aid and for the service event triggering the time limit. A general enquiry to a law firm does not replace a request to the court.

How does renewal differ from other remedies?

New facts or new evidence capable of supporting an acquittal or conviction under a more lenient criminal statute belong to the separate assessment of reopening under § 353 StPO. A substantiated Convention complaint is instead required for an extended renewal application. Where an ECtHR judgment concerning your own proceedings already exists, the renewal procedure expressly provided for by statute requires separate assessment. Choice of procedure also matters in detention cases: where the GRBG applies, a complaint concerning the right to personal liberty under Art 5 ECHR is governed by the fundamental rights complaint under that Act. An excluded detention remedy is not substituted by renewal. A different assessment may be required for other Convention rights affected during detention. Sentence-enforcement matters originally decided by the prison authority are subject to separate jurisdictional rules. A general right to seek renewal against every detention or prison decision is not established by this.

What can the Supreme Court decide and what should you prepare?

During private deliberations, the Supreme Court may reject an application that is inadmissible or manifestly unfounded. Should the application succeed, the concerned criminal court decision is set aside and the matter is referred to the Regional Court or Higher Regional Court where necessary. Acquittal does not automatically result from this. Enforcement is not itself stopped by filing the application; according to 12 Os 37/26x, legislation does not provide for a request to grant suspensive effect. The complete final-instance decision, preceding decisions, all appeal submissions and records of service are required for legal assessment. Also identify where the particular Convention complaint was raised earlier. Whether another remedy, a timely request for legal aid defence counsel or preparation of a renewal application is the appropriate next step is established by these documents. If a deadline is running, send the decision and service date immediately.

Frequently asked questions

Extended renewal application: Convention complaint without an ECtHR judgment

Must I first wait for a judgment from Strasbourg? +

A prior ECtHR judgment is not necessarily required for an extended renewal application. Included among the relevant requirements are a specific Convention violation by a lower criminal court, personal victim status, exhaustion of remedies, a time limit, and form. The statutory procedure following an ECtHR judgment constitutes a separate situation.

Is the time limit six months or four months? +

A four-month time limit following the final domestic decision now generally applies to applications within the extended scope. The reduction was expressly confirmed by the Supreme Court in 15 Os 78/23v. When assessing the actual deadline, the decision and service records must be considered together.

Can defence counsel add the signature later? +

That must not be relied upon. Under 13 Os 92/24i, the absence of a defence counsel's signature on a fully argued renewal application cannot be remedied. A timely request for the appointment of legal aid defence counsel to prepare the remedy constitutes a separate procedural step.

Does the application stop enforcement of my sentence? +

Enforcement is not automatically stopped by filing the application. Under 12 Os 37/26x, legislation does not provide for a request to grant suspensive effect. Sentence-enforcement issues and any other possible applications must be assessed under their own requirements.

Interview, house search, indictment?

In criminal matters every hour counts. Call us directly or send an email, callback within one business day, earlier in urgent cases.

Contact

A direct line to the firm.

Address

BRANDAUER Rechtsanwälte GmbH Giselakai 51 5020 Salzburg