Reconstruct knowledge and the specific order
Preserve orders, amendments and the timing of knowledge unchanged. Have individual use and the statutory transaction or order amount assessed.
Insider dealing allegations in Austria: reconstruct individual knowledge, orders and recommendations and distinguish the criminal thresholds under § 163 BörseG.
Mag. Christopher Angerer, Rechtsanwalt
Your lawyer for criminal defence
Criminal proceedings are a matter of trust. One lawyer who walks with you from the first consultation through to the trial, everything from one hand.
The act of trading securities shortly before a market announcement does not, by itself, establish insider dealing. An allegation under § 163 BörseG depends on the specific information, the individual trader's knowledge, and the use of that information in the transaction concerned. Separate requirements apply to recommendations and unlawful disclosures. Therefore, directors, employees, and advisers should have the information and trading sequence examined for each person before responding to a suspicion.
Choose the act concerned. This selection does not replace individual legal assessment.
You already know that you want to contact us? Go directly to the enquiry form.
Preserve orders, amendments and the timing of knowledge unchanged. Have individual use and the statutory transaction or order amount assessed.
Preserve the exact content of the communication. Have your role, its connection to the information and the statutory market conditions assessed.
Preserve the original content and identify recipients. Normal professional disclosure and the knowledge held need examination in the particular case.
Have the authority’s document and the identified act examined. Clarify the allegation and accessible case file before deciding on a statement.
Art. 7 MAR defines inside information for securities as precise information that remains unpublished and pertains directly or indirectly to an issuer or a financial instrument. Should such information become public, a significant effect on the price must be probable. The criterion is whether a reasonable investor would likely incorporate it into the basis of an investment decision. This assessment, viewed from the perspective at the time, is not superseded by any subsequent price movement. Furthermore, general expectations and published facts must be distinguished from additional specific internal information.
If an intermediate step in a prolonged transaction satisfies the requirements, it may itself be inside information. The final agreement or later market announcement is therefore not automatically the first legally relevant point. Each stage of negotiations needs to be recorded by date and content. Specific categories for commodity derivatives, emission allowances and pending client orders are contained in Art. 7 MAR. The classification of the information depends on the instrument concerned and the particular information.
Insiders with access through a management or supervisory position, a capital holding, employment, profession or duties, and persons who obtain the information through criminal acts are covered by § 163 Abs. 4 BörseG. What a particular person knew at a particular time is not established by a board position or advisory appointment. Attendance at meetings, documents actually received and the content of communications must be distinguished. The knowledge of a colleague must not simply be attributed to the person placing an order.
For other recipients of information, § 163 Abs. 5 bis 7 BörseG distinguishes use, recommendation and disclosure. Separate examination is required for the knowledge expressly mandated by those provisions. MAR wording referring to circumstances a person knows or ought to know cannot simply be transposed to these criminal offences. Therefore, the defence examines the origin and content of the information, the recipient's understanding and the time at which individual knowledge can be demonstrated.
Acquiring or disposing of relevant financial instruments or auctioned products based on emission allowances for more than one million euros using inside information, as well as the cancellation or amendment, in an amount exceeding one million euros, of corresponding orders placed before the information was obtained, are acts for which § 163 Abs. 1 BörseG provides for six months to five years' imprisonment. Corresponding acts are specified by the provision for bids on emission allowances and related auctioned products. The transaction or order amount covered by the statute, not a profit of one million euros, constitutes the relevant measure.
Knowingly obtaining inside information or a recommendation from an insider and using it in the ways specified in Abs. 1 falls under § 163 Abs. 5 BörseG. The sentencing range remains six months to five years. The examination must cover the financial instruments within Abs. 8, the economic amount, and the particular use. A 35 percent price change and ten million euros in market turnover are not general additional conditions for these trading cases. Multiple orders and partial executions require a reasoned legal allocation of their values.
A penalty of six months to five years' imprisonment applies to a recommendation by an insider under § 163 Abs. 2 BörseG and to a knowing recommendation under Abs. 6. In addition, during the five trading days following the inside information becoming known, a price change of at least 35 percent and a total turnover of at least ten million euros on the most relevant market in terms of liquidity must occur in the financial instruments. Both market conditions belong to these offences. The threshold for a person's own trading must not automatically be treated as a requirement for every recommendation.
If the market conditions in Abs. 2 occur, unlawful disclosures under § 163 Abs. 3 und 7 BörseG carry up to two years' imprisonment. Under Art. 10 MAR, an examination is necessary to determine whether disclosure took place in the normal exercise of employment, a profession or duties. Participation and attempt are excluded by the statute for Abs. 2 und 6, while attempt is excluded for Abs. 3 und 7. Merely contributing to the use of a recommendation is exempted by Abs. 5. Each exception applies to the expressly identified situation.
Legitimate behaviour is addressed by Art. 9 MAR. For a legal person, effective internal procedures established beforehand may be relevant if the individuals deciding or influencing the trade do not possess the inside information and the informed legal person does not encourage, recommend, induce or otherwise influence the individual executing the trade. These questions are not answered by the mere existence of an internal policy. Examination is required for actual information barriers and decision-making routes. Specific requirements also apply to certain ordinary activities of market makers and persons executing orders.
Where a transaction discharges an obligation that has become due, in good faith and without circumventing the insider dealing prohibition, an obligation established before the information was obtained may be relevant under Art. 9 Abs. 3 MAR. An old order therefore provides no blanket exemption for later changes. Further provisions concern public takeovers and mergers and mere knowledge of one's own trading intention. Examination of an illegitimate reason is expressly preserved by Art. 9 Abs. 6 MAR. The requirements of the particular situation remain decisive.
The absence of a requirement for a criminal offence does not rule out an infringement of the insider dealing prohibition. Art. 14 MAR prohibits insider dealing, specified recommendations and unlawful disclosures. For the infringements it covers, § 154 BörseG provides for FMA administrative fines of up to five million euros or up to three times the quantifiable benefit, including losses avoided. The existence of an infringement and the required culpability must still be assessed independently. A smaller transaction is therefore no reliable test of lawful conduct.
The defence assessment must begin with jurisdiction. Pursuant to the principle in § 22 Abs. 1 VStG, conduct constitutes a punishable administrative offence only if it does not constitute an offence within the courts' jurisdiction, unless administrative legislation provides otherwise. Consequently, initial contact from the FMA establishes neither a guaranteed limitation to administrative proceedings nor automatic double punishment. The assessment is determined by the allegation, the act concerned, and the provisions applicable at the time of the conduct.
Each person's access to information is linked by a useful chronology to the decision and its technical execution. Original orders, amendments, cancellations, broker confirmations, communications, and demonstrable public disclosure constitute relevant records. Timestamps require reconciliation with their time zone and system source. Although an access record may be important circumstantial evidence, a document in a data room does not by itself prove that it was read. Identification is also necessary of who merely executed an order technically and who influenced its substance.
The market and time window relevant under the statute must be shown by price and turnover data. From the perspective at the time, likely significant price impact under Art. 7 MAR must be assessed. Different functions are served by the subsequent market response and the additional market conditions in particular statutory paragraphs. Alongside incriminating messages, exculpatory decision records, pre-existing obligations and information barriers belong in the examination. Records and devices should be preserved unchanged, with subsequent additions clearly identifiable as such.
Following a summons, the initial inquiry concerns which act is alleged against which person and in which proceedings. Accused persons are granted rights by § 49 StPO, including the selection of defence counsel, access to the case file, and the determination of whether to comment on the allegation or remain silent. If other orders or messages are unknown, a spontaneous explanation of one conspicuous trade may be incomplete. Consequently, legal preparation unites the available information, trading data, and criminal thresholds prior to a decision on giving a statement.
An outline of the document received, the authority making the allegation, and the act concerned suffices for an initial enquiry. Full trading lists, internal company information, and communication archives should be provided only through an agreed secure channel for the engagement. Mag. Christopher Angerer, Rechtsanwalt, examines the individual criminal allegation and the next defence steps. Where several people are involved, it is also important to clarify early whether their interests require separate representation.
That question cannot be answered by the amount alone. Separate assessment is required for the criminal trading threshold under § 163 Abs. 1 BörseG and for administrative liability under § 154 BörseG. Their own statutory requirements apply to recommendations and disclosures.
There is no general requirement under § 163 Abs. 1 BörseG to have made an actual profit. The examination focuses in particular on the inside information, its use, and the transaction amount covered by the statute. A sale to avoid a loss may also be relevant.
Temporal proximity may serve as circumstantial evidence. Neither the individual's specific knowledge nor the use of inside information is established by temporal proximity alone. For each person concerned, the information and decision-making sequence, along with the other requirements, must be examined.
In criminal matters every hour counts. Call us directly or send an email, callback within one business day, earlier in urgent cases.
Address
BRANDAUER Rechtsanwälte GmbH Giselakai 51 5020 Salzburg
Phone
+43 660 2407152