Examine manufacture and payment separately
Have the alleged manufacture, the payment process and the intent required at each stage examined separately against the case file.
Buying valuable goods with counterfeit money: why counterfeiting and fraud may both be charged, and how the defence examines intent and evidence in Austria.
Mag. Christopher Angerer, Rechtsanwalt
Your lawyer for criminal defence
Criminal proceedings are a matter of trust. One lawyer who walks with you from the first consultation through to the trial, everything from one hand.
If a person counterfeits money and uses it to induce a seller to hand over valuable goods, that person may face both counterfeiting and fraud charges. The connection between making the money and paying with it does not automatically remove the fraud allegation. Nevertheless, each charge requires specific findings about the conduct and intent.
The Austrian Supreme Court, in its 24 October 2023 decision 14 Os 98/23b, explained why both offences can apply and overturned one participant’s conviction because the reasons given for finding intent were incomplete. Consequently, your defence needs to address two levels: the legal classification and proof of what you knew and intended at each stage.
Would you like to discuss the case?
Have the alleged manufacture, the payment process and the intent required at each stage examined separately against the case file.
Have the alleged assistance and the evidence of your knowledge of the counterfeit-money transaction examined.
Have the concurrence of offences, overlooked exculpatory statements and the sentencing framework examined. Call directly if an appeal deadline is running.
§ 232 Abs. 1 StGB addresses making counterfeit money or altering money. The required intent concerns putting that money into circulation as genuine and unaltered. A subsequent fraud under § 146 StGB requires further elements: deception about facts, a resulting disposition of property, financial loss, and intent to obtain an unlawful benefit for yourself or a third party through that disposition.
The Supreme Court case actually addressed the receipt of counterfeit banknotes under § 232 Abs. 2 StGB and the later acquisition of two watches, and the appellant was accused of contributing to these offences. Consequently, the judgment does not establish that this defendant manufactured the money himself. In a manufacture case, one must keep the stages separate: who allegedly made the money, who handed it over, and why did the seller release the goods?
§ 232 StGB safeguards public confidence in the security and reliability of payment transactions involving valid money, while § 146 StGB protects individual property interests. When a seller, induced by a purported genuine payment, hands over a watch and suffers a loss, that loss affects a further protected interest. Consequently, counterfeiting alone does not account for the full wrong involved in the subsequent purchase.
The Supreme Court rejected the implied subsidiarity of fraud to counterfeiting in paragraphs 7 to 16. This rejection means that fraud does not fall away simply because the other offence has also been committed. § 146 StGB contains no express clause to that effect either. Speciality is likewise not the applicable test for several independent acts, since speciality concerns a specific offence incorporating every element of a more general one. Examining concurrence never replaces proof of the elements of each offence.
An unpunished subsequent act requires certain conditions. The later conduct must exploit the result of the principal offence or maintain the unlawful situation it created, affect the same legally protected interest, and cause no additional harm. The fact that payment follows counterfeiting in time or was planned from the outset is insufficient for the later offence to be absorbed.
In paragraphs 17 and 18, the Supreme Court rejected absorption on that basis. Counterfeiting harmed the public, but the subsequent fraud caused financial loss to the watch seller. Consequently, merely describing payment as the use of counterfeit money provides the defence with no automatic ground to remove the fraud charge. The court must still examine the actual deception, the handover of goods, and the alleged loss.
The legal possibility that both offences apply does not establish your intent. For manufacture, the question is whether the intent covered later circulation as genuine money. For fraud, the findings must also cover deception, loss, and unlawful enrichment. Where an escort or helper is involved, the court must separately establish what conduct the assistance was intended to support and what the person knew about it. Merely accompanying a transaction does not answer those questions.
In the decided case, the appellant stated that he had served as a paid security escort for what he believed was a lawful transaction, and a co-defendant supported this account. Although the trial court otherwise regarded the co-defendant’s evidence as largely credible, it overlooked the exculpatory statements concerning the escort’s role. In paragraph 4, the Supreme Court criticised these incomplete reasons, overturned the conviction, and ordered a new trial. This outcome was neither an acquittal nor a finding that the escort necessarily acted in good faith.
§ 28 StGB governs the determination of the sentence where several offences are adjudicated together. Where the applicable provisions prescribe imprisonment, the court generally imposes a single prison sentence under the provision carrying the highest penalty. Subject to extraordinary mitigation, the court must also respect the highest applicable minimum. Convictions for two offences therefore do not mean mechanically adding two separate sentences.
§ 232 Abs. 1 StGB sets the sentencing framework for counterfeiting at imprisonment from one to ten years. The applicable penalty in an individual case depends on any other established offences and aggravating forms. The value of the purchased goods alone does not determine the actual sentence. The defence must examine the statutory sentencing framework separately from the assessment of the individual sentence.
A timeline of each person’s alleged conduct serves as the starting point. This timeline should cover the attribution of manufacture, the origin and handover of the banknotes, communications preceding the transaction, and the handover of the goods. Expert reports or seized devices may matter to the allegation of manufacture. Messages and statements may show whether a person knew the real purpose of the transaction. A single item of evidence may address several questions, and its significance requires reasons in each context.
Leave existing messages, purchase documents, and official correspondence unchanged. For an initial legal assessment, the precise allegation, the next appointment and known exculpatory statements are particularly useful. Mag. Christopher Angerer examines the case file to assess which allegations the evidence supports and which objections are available at the relevant procedural stage. Make contact promptly if a judgment has already been served or questioning is imminent.
The alleged manufacture does not automatically remove the fraud charge. The later purchase requires independent proof of deception, financial loss and the required intent. Different legally protected interests may support convictions for both offences.
The Supreme Court overturned the appellant’s conviction and remitted the case for a new trial because the reasons concerning the subjective elements of his offences were incomplete. Its explanation of the possible concurrence of counterfeiting and fraud is a separate issue.
The evidence must also establish an escort’s contribution and intent. Exculpatory statements may be decisive. Acting as a security escort or being present at the handover does not replace the examination of personal knowledge of the criminal conduct.
In criminal matters every hour counts. Call us directly or send an email, callback within one business day, earlier in urgent cases.
Address
BRANDAUER Rechtsanwälte GmbH Giselakai 51 5020 Salzburg
Phone
+43 660 2407152