A fixed sentence for a confession: Responding to unlawful judicial deals
An informal judicial promise of a fixed sentence for a confession is unlawful in Austria. Protect your choice to speak and document what happened.
Mag. Christopher Angerer, Rechtsanwalt
Your lawyer for criminal defence
Criminal proceedings are a matter of trust. One lawyer who walks with you from the first consultation through to the trial, everything from one hand.
A reliable basis for a decision in Austrian criminal proceedings is not an informal judicial promise of a particular sentence in exchange for a confession. Such agreements about the judgment are unlawful. If a fixed sentence is held out in return for a particular statement, the exact offer should be clarified with your defence lawyer before responding to the charge, and a record of what happened must be preserved.
At sentencing, a confession can matter. An entitlement to a negotiated sentence is not created by it. Particularly where imprisonment is at stake, knowledge of the case file and an independent assessment must underpin the decision whether to speak. If you have already relied on a promise and made a statement, have the statement, the conversation, and the procedural stage examined together.
Which situation would you like assessed?
Would you like to discuss the case?
How far has the discussion about a specific sentence progressed?
Your answers so far
Distinguish legal information from a promised result.
Examine the statement and how it came about together.
Why a fixed sentence cannot be promised for a confession
Why a fixed sentence cannot be promised for a confession
In legal principle RS0119311, originating from 11 Os 77/04 of 24 August 2004, an agreement between judge and defence lawyer on numerically fixed effects of the accused person's statements on the sentence is rejected in principle by the Austrian Supreme Court. The central reason is its conflict with establishing the material truth. A contract with the accused about guilt and punishment cannot be made by the court.
An offer conveyed through the defence lawyer is also subject to this boundary. Whether particular statements are linked to a predetermined outcome in the judgment constitutes the decisive question. Under § 258 Abs. 2 StPO, the evidence must be examined conscientiously by the court, both individually and in its overall context. That assessment cannot be replaced by an agreement on the desired result.
How a legal assessment differs from a sentence deal
How a legal assessment differs from a sentence deal
The statutory significance of a confession may be explained by your defence lawyer, who may also provide a reasoned forecast based on the file. A remorseful confession or a substantial contribution to establishing the truth through a statement is identified by § 34 Abs. 1 Z 17 StGB as a mitigating factor. No fixed sentence reduction for it is set by the law. An assessment must acknowledge its uncertainties, and a judicial promise of an outcome must not be presented as a secured benefit.
The question is whether the discussion merely explained a statutory mitigating factor or promised a specific sentence in exchange for a particular statement. The Supreme Court expressly distinguishes such agreements from the statutory steps towards diversion. Diversion under §§ 198 ff StPO has its own conditions and is not a negotiated sentencing judgment. The legal substance of a conversation is not changed by calling it an understanding.
How to respond before making another statement
How to respond before making another statement
Your freedom to speak or remain silent and your right to legal defence at every stage are protected by § 7 StPO. For questioning the accused at trial, § 245 Abs. 2 StPO refers to the prohibited methods in § 164 Abs. 4 StPO. To obtain a confession or other information, promises must not be used. You are not obliged to confess by an informal promise.
Who mentioned which sentence and on what conditions must first be clarified. If advice is needed, a break may be requested by your lawyer; however, the granting of such a request is not guaranteed. Under § 245 Abs. 3 StPO, you may confer with your lawyer during the trial, but consultation regarding the answering of individual questions is not permitted. Your further decision whether to speak should follow an examination of the evidence and the specific charge.
How to preserve an accurate account of the conversation
How to preserve an accurate account of the conversation
The wording, date, place, and people present should be noted promptly as accurately as possible. It should be recorded whether the remark was allegedly made during the hearing, during a break, or only to the defence lawyer. Your own observations should be separated from information supplied by others, and recollections that convey only the gist should be identified. Conditions also matter, such as a required account of events or abandoning further applications for evidence.
Pursuant to § 271 Abs. 1 StPO, the recording of individual points in the trial minutes may be requested by parties to preserve their rights, and applications together with the decisions thereon also belong in the minutes. A clear record of the specific incident and the objection should be sought by your lawyer. While a private note supplements the documentation, it does not replace the court record, and the recording of an agreement does not make it lawful.
What needs examining if you have already confessed
What needs examining if you have already confessed
Later distancing from a statement already made does not automatically erase it. Where statements differ, § 245 Abs. 1 StPO provides for asking about the reasons and permits earlier statements to be read out under the conditions stated there. The defence must therefore examine how the confession arose and its contents alongside the other evidence. Merely changing your account does not resolve the problem of the promise.
What can be established and the conditions of the relevant procedural remedy determine whether an unlawful agreement affects the use of evidence or a judicial decision. If judgment has already been delivered, the court's composition, service, and the procedural stage also matter. The prohibition alone entails no automatic quashing or reopening and no specific reduction in sentence. The appropriate remedy and its time limits should be assessed individually without delay.
What documents an independent defence assessment needs
What documents an independent defence assessment needs
The indictment, summons, available trial minutes, and, where applicable, the judgment and records of service should be brought to the consultation. Unaltered messages or letters concerning the alleged promise and your prompt written recollection should be added. If the offer was only passed on orally, it is particularly important to establish who personally heard the original remark and which parts were understood merely as an assessment.
The question of which statement is factually correct and useful for the defence is separated by the legal assessment from the alleged agreement. Unresolved evidential issues and a comparison of the minutes with the actual conversation are included. If the previous lawyer took part in the disputed discussion and disagreement exists about it, an independent second assessment can help clarify roles and next steps. A particular outcome cannot be promised.
Questions about judicial promises of a sentence
Does written confirmation make the deal binding? +
Is the agreement lawful if my lawyer negotiated it? +
Do I receive a fixed sentence discount for confessing? +
Questioning, trial minutes and statutory alternatives
Interview, house search, indictment?
In criminal matters every hour counts. Call us directly or send an email, callback within one business day, earlier in urgent cases.
A direct line to the firm.
Address
BRANDAUER Rechtsanwälte GmbH Giselakai 51 5020 Salzburg
Phone
+43 660 2407152